Lessons Learned From Compromised Digital Certificate Incidents

Digital certificates play a pivotal role in ensuring trust, encryption and secure communications and transactions. However, even slight lapses in certificate management can have severe consequences, as demonstrated by several high-profile breaches. These incidents serve as stark reminders of the importance of robust certificate lifecycle management and secure PKI practices to mitigate the potential risks associated with overlooking or mismanaging certificates.

Lessons Learned from Compromised Digital Certificates-1 (1)

Here, we will analyze notable certificate-related breaches and security incidents from the past few years, identify the root causes and vulnerabilities that led to these incidents, and highlight how certificate lifecycle management (CLM) solutions, like the AppViewX AVX ONE Platform, can help organizations avoid similar pitfalls.

1. The GDPR Breach at Marriott Hotels: The Cost of Undetected Certificate Mismanagement

In 2018, Marriott Hotels disclosed a massive data breach that exposed the personal identifiable information (PII) of up to 500 million guests. The breach was facilitated by an unauthorized third-party using a compromised certificate to access the hotel’s guest reservation system.

Root Cause: The breach resulted from the hotel’s failure to properly monitor and detect the unauthorized use of a compromised certificate, allowing the attacker to maintain access to their systems for an extended period.

How AppViewX AVX ONE Can Help:

– The certificate monitoring and alerting capabilities of the AVX ONE CLM solution enable organizations to detect unauthorized or anomalous certificate usage in real-time, mitigating the risk of undetected breaches.

– The centralized certificate inventory and reporting features provide visibility into the entire certificate landscape, making it easier to identify and revoke compromised or rogue certificates promptly.

2. The Twitter Certificate Mishap: The Risks of Manual Certificate Management

In 2022, Twitter experienced a widespread outage due to an expired certificate that went unnoticed and unrenewed. The incident highlighted the risks associated with manual certificate management processes and the potential impact on business continuity.

Root Cause: The Twitter outage was caused by an expired certificate that was not promptly renewed, leading to disruptions in the company’s internal tools and services.

How AppViewX Can Help:

– AppViewX AVX ONE provides automated certificate discovery, monitoring, and renewal processes that eliminate the need for manual interventions, reducing the risk of human errors and overlooked expirations.

– The CLM platform’s robust alerting and notification systems ensure timely awareness of upcoming certificate expirations, enabling proactive renewal and minimizing the risk of service disruptions.

3. The SolarWinds Software Supply Chain Attack: The Importance of Secure Code Signing Practices

In 2020, the SolarWinds software supply chain attack compromised the company’s software build system, allowing attackers to inject malicious code into software updates and distribute them with valid code-signing certificates.

Root Cause: The security incident was facilitated by the attackers’ ability to compromise SolarWinds’ build system and obtain access to their code-signing certificates, enabling them to distribute malicious software updates with valid signatures.

How AppViewX Can Help:

– AppViewX provides secure code-signing certificate management capabilities that enable organizations to maintain tight control over their code-signing infrastructure and protect their private keys from unauthorized access.

– Regular certificate and key rotation and renewal features help limit the potential impact of a compromise by ensuring that compromised certificates are promptly replaced.

Prevent outages, eliminate security weaknesses and reduce risk across hybrid multi-cloud environments

Other Notable Certificate-Related Incidents

  1. Google Workspace Certificate Expiry (2022)
    • Overview: In December 2022, an expired certificate caused significant disruptions for Google Workspace users. This resulted in service outages affecting Gmail, Google Drive, and other Google services.
    • Impact: The outage impacted millions of users globally, leading to productivity losses and user frustration.
    • Root Cause: Failure to renew an essential certificate on time, highlighting inadequate certificate management practices.
  2. Let’s Encrypt Root Certificate Expiry (2021/2022)
    • Overview: The expiry of Let’s Encrypt’s root certificate caused compatibility issues for older devices and systems that did not recognize the new root certificate.
    • Impact: Users of older devices and software experienced connection failures and security warnings.
    • Root Cause: Insufficient preparation and communication regarding the certificate transition, affecting legacy systems and devices.
  3. Microsoft Azure SSL/TLS Certificate Issue (2022)
    • Overview: In February 2022, Microsoft Azure experienced issues related to an expired SSL certificate, causing service disruptions across multiple regions.
    • Impact: The incident led to significant downtime for Azure customers, affecting business operations and causing financial losses.
    • Root Cause: Lack of proactive monitoring and automated renewal for critical SSL certificates.

Root Causes and Vulnerabilities

  1. Inadequate Certificate Management: Failure to track, renew, and manage certificates in a timely manner can lead to service outages and security vulnerabilities. Manual processes and lack of automation contribute to these issues.
  2. Insufficient Communication and Preparation: Poor communication and lack of preparation for certificate transitions can cause widespread compatibility issues, especially for older devices and legacy systems.
  3. Lack of Proactive Monitoring: Without proactive monitoring and alerts for certificate expiry, organizations are at risk of unexpected service disruptions and potential security breaches.
  4. Weak Certificate Storage Security: Inadequate protection of certificate storage allows attackers to compromise and misuse certificates, undermining trust in digital communications.

How AppViewX Can Help

AppViewX provides a comprehensive solution to address the challenges highlighted by these incidents, offering advanced tools and features designed to enhance security, automate processes, and ensure compliance with industry standards.

  1. Automated Certificate Management: AppViewX AVX ONE CLM platform automates the entire lifecycle of digital certificates, from issuance to renewal and revocation. This reduces the risk of human error and ensures that certificates are always up-to-date, preventing service disruptions like those seen in the Google Workspace and Microsoft Azure incidents.
  2. Proactive Monitoring and Alerts: The platform offers proactive monitoring and real-time alerts. Continuous tracking of certificate status and timely notifications for impending expirations or anomalies help prevent unexpected outages and enhance overall security posture.
  3. Secure Certificate Storage: AppViewX employs robust security measures for certificate and key storage, including strong encryption, stringent access controls and use of hardware security modules (HSMs). These measures protect certificates and keys from unauthorized access and misuse, mitigating risks similar to the SolarWinds certificate compromise.
  4. Seamless Integration and Compatibility: The platform provides seamless integration with various devices, systems, and Certificate Authorities (CAs). This ensures compatibility across diverse environments, addressing issues like the Let’s Encrypt root certificate expiry by simplifying transitions and maintaining trust in digital communications.
  5. Comprehensive Auditing and Reporting: AppViewX delivers detailed auditing and reporting capabilities, allowing organizations to track certificate usage and compliance with internal policies and industry regulations. Regular audits help identify and rectify vulnerabilities, ensuring continuous improvement in security practices.
  6. Expert Support and Training: Beyond technical solutions, AppViewX offers expert support and training for IT and security personnel. This empowers organizations to stay ahead of emerging threats and maintain best practices in certificate management.

By learning from the lessons of these recent breaches and implementing proactive certificate lifecycle management solutions, organizations can significantly reduce the risks associated with certificate management and maintain a strong security posture, ensuring the integrity and confidentiality of their digital communications, transactions, and software supply chain. To learn more about how AppViewX can help, request a personalized demo of the AVX ONE Certificate Lifecycle Management and PKI Platform today.


  • Certificate Discovery
  • certificate lifecycle management solutions
  • Certificate Management
  • Certificate Monitoring
  • Certificate Outage
  • certificate renewal
  • Digital Certificates
  • PKI

About the Author

Anandhi Venkataraman

Product Management

More From the Author →

Related Articles

Attention: Google To Distrust Entrust TLS Certificates

| 5 Min Read

AppViewX AVX ONE Certificate Lifecycle Management Integration With HashiCorp Vault

| 4 Min Read

Simplifying Azure Key Vault Updates With AppViewX Automation

| 3 Min Read